Diabolically Arcane

Puzzles, posts, news and general word-chat.

November 08 2011

Dos & Don'ts

moses

Plenty of aspiring solvers contact this blog in hope of cryptic tips. (Plenty of aspiring setters too, but that’s for another post.) Enough to inspire this week’s Storm, where we compose the Ten Commandments of Cryptics. (And if that sounds too august for a November lark, then what say we also draft a far from helpful ten?)

The best rules – both the orthodox and unorthodox versions – will end up on this blog as its own discrete document, as well be enshrined in a future Wordplay column.

Keep your eyes on the punchy, the precise & the particular, though sometimes wisdom (and humour) need to take other tangents. Here are some examples below. See if you separate the sage from the silly:

Mistrust every word on the page. If it waddles, quacks, and lives in the reeds, doesn’t mean it’s a duck.

Always use pen.

If a word fits, bung it in.

When first starting, measure the next day’s answers against the clues, and see if you can detect how one gives the other.

Araucaria is Latin for too easy.

If a crossword comes with extra solving instructions, then run the other way.

(This last precept could be sage or silly, depending on your viewpoint.) But you get the idea. Just think what tips really opened the door for you. A word from a drinking mate? Chapter 11 in Puzzled? Finding the right level of clues for starters?

And by the same token, what hint would kick you back into the morass? Give us your insights, and perversity, and see if we can’t promulgate 20 Commandments – the priceless and the senseless. Lawmakers, please file your commendations before Thursday, 6pm.

Comments

JD — 08 November at 07:36AM

This almost becomes my mantra if I am feeling lost: "Every word is there for a reason".

Em — 08 November at 08:18AM

DA cryptics are a walk in the park. Start with those.

RobT — 08 November at 08:22AM

When in doubt, chuck letters about.

RobT — 08 November at 08:25AM

Notwithstanding DA, the Sabbath Day is insufficient to maintain one's mettle.

Mauve — 08 November at 08:25AM

There's almost certainly one container on the page and almost certainly not two.

If the clue seems impossibly short, it's a double meaning disguised by cunning surface sense. (two DA examples: bright pink = gay, America says = states)

RobT — 08 November at 08:26AM

Antipodean cryptics are funner but impreciser than those from the UK.

Boniface — 08 November at 08:29AM

Sage:

Try to identify the definition and wordplay elements of the clue.

Read books like Puzzled and learn the different clueing techniques and signposts.

Look for special tricks like Ninas and pangrams. They can help too!

Silly:

If a word fits, bung it in - if nothing else fits! [You'd be surprised how often this has worked for me...]

Words like "upset", "about" and "around" are always anagram signposts.

JD — 08 November at 08:52AM

The imagery provided by the clue will generally have no connection with the actual answer.

DA2 — 08 November at 09:00AM

Regularly has nothing to do with All Bran, but everything to do with ALRN or LBA.

RobT — 08 November at 09:11AM

If you go "oh!" to yourself (silently or out loud) you have just solved a very clever or funny clue.

Depsite every indication to the contrary, each setter wants you to solve his/her puzzle.

Mr X — 08 November at 09:40AM

Learning to do cryptics is just like becoming part of any clique at school. Keep hanging around until you've picked up the in-jokes. Once you've got them, cryptics are easier than quicks as you get 2 clues for every answer.
If you want to fast track, look up fifteensquared - a website which breaks down the UKs leading cryptics.

JD — 08 November at 09:50AM

Put the crossword and a pen on the bedside table before you go to bed - so often the solutions appear to the semi-conscious mind.

Sam — 08 November at 11:16AM

‘According to Spooner’ or ‘Spooner says’ doesn’t refer to the Australian cartoonist (as I once thought… ) but to the Reverend Spooner, who became famous - perhaps unjustly - for switching initial fragments of words (can be a single letter, or sound-shift) completely changing the meaning. For example DA recently clued the man himself as a ‘bird watcher’ or a ‘word botcher.’

RobT — 08 November at 11:33AM

The use of the word "say" almost always relates to an example, whereas "we hear" almost always relates to a homophone.

RK — 08 November at 11:39AM

If you're clueless about cricket, you're in big trouble.

Anthony Douglas — 08 November at 11:42AM

1. Don't enter an answer unless you can see how it fits both wordplay and definition.

10. Expect exceptions to all of the above.

JD — 08 November at 11:45AM

Beware the 'er' ending! Words like flower and number don't mean what you expect them to. (except for the rare occasions when they actually do, which makes it even trickier).

JD — 08 November at 12:17PM

Brush up on your Roman numerals.

Em — 08 November at 12:17PM

Heads up - 'heads up' could mean 'U'. 'Heads up could mean' could mean 'HUCM'. And so on.

Em — 08 November at 12:18PM

Aaargh. 'Heads up could mean' could mean 'UCM'. And so on. Back to Cryptics 101 for me.

RobT — 08 November at 01:27PM

Or sdaeh.

DA2 — 08 November at 01:51PM

When you see ellipses (....), maintain your pulse rate.

Mauve — 08 November at 02:16PM

I agree with Anthony Douglas, who expects excepts

KM — 08 November at 02:57PM

Do your cryptic crosswords on the bus so everyone can see how smart you are, especially on Fridays.

Never assume... like emus run backwards!

Solving cryptics is like playing charades, only no-one looks silly.

Practise writing clues to get inside the minds of your tormentors.

Cluers often speak in tongues - mainly French, German, Italian and Spanish.

KM — 08 November at 03:02PM

If the definition isn't at one end, it's at the other. Mostly.

KM — 08 November at 03:05PM

Search for commonly grouped letters in apparent anagram fodder, like '-ing', '-ous', '-ant', '-ion', etc.

KM — 08 November at 03:06PM

Do not solve while driving.

Mr X — 08 November at 03:08PM

If you can't crack a particular crossword, just claim that the setter isn't Ximenean enough.

DA2 — 08 November at 03:56PM

3 inside a phrase is more likely to be THE than ELK or WAX.

dg — 08 November at 05:11PM

Make sure you mark the word break spaces in any phrase.
-----------

If at first you don't succeed take a break. Also if the answer grid for yesterday's cryptic is provided sometimes reading out each of yesterday's answers can put you a little more in crossword-solving mode.

Sometimes having a go at the traditional crossword, or other puzzles, on the same page can also help.
-----------

For anagrams write out the letters as a row of consonants above a row of vowels. (or vice versa) e.g.

R T C S W D S R R Y C P C
I O O

When doing this it's a good idea to take the first consonant or vowel from the back, then front then back again alternating.

i.e.

the letters in "a rope ends it" would be transcribed:

TRSPDN
IAEOE

This helps 'unscramble' the way the setter has the letters....set.

-------------------

Get some exercise. I was struggling solving cryptics for weeks and then after moving much more my brain seems more attuned.

--------------------

If you have a rough idea for part or all an answer try solving the intersecting clue(s) with what would be the intersecting letter(s).

If that doing that doesnt totally invalidate your educated guess write it in lightly and with smaller font and place a question mark beside it in the margin.

---------------

Take good note that there are few 1, 2 and 3 letter words and few letters that come after an apostrophe. Words often end in S, T, Y, D or N. If a word could be a plural, past tense or superlative remember they'll often finish in S, T/D or ER respectively.

--------------------

That said, nothing is set in concrete: words can have Q as their final letter or they may not be traditional English (or even English) words. And watch out for compound words in general - they can have strange combinations like 'TCHST' or "CKB" in the middle.

-----------------

Don't ignore the little words like "IN".
----------------

(Sorry if some of this is bleeding obvious)

JD — 08 November at 05:18PM

Read out the clue accenting a different word each time.

SK — 08 November at 06:15PM

I guess everybody has there own technique, but for me there are a few simple rules that help, particularly with a gnarly DA...

(1) In order to get the creative cells functioning, it is a good idea to consume alcohol while solving

(2) Regarding (1), it is suggested that restraint be exercised. It is recommended that a glass or two of wine is preferable to a line of tequila shots

(3) Regarding (2), choice of venue is important. A quiet corner at home is the ideal location. It is not recommended to attempt a DA cryptic in a night club. It is a bad idea on so many levels.

Anyway, they are my sage ideas. Will give some thought to some silly tips...

— 08 November at 07:26PM

Don't stew. Give yourself a time limit and happily start afresh on another.

JPR — 08 November at 07:29PM

Know thine setter

RobT — 08 November at 07:42PM

L-players are well-advised to start at the end where shorter answers are often more easily found, so building a platform for up up and awayness.

RobT — 08 November at 08:12PM

For anagrams write out the number of underscores hangman-style, fill in any known letters and then think of common prefixes and suffixes, or letter combos, that might fit. Sometimes only one of your letters could possibly fit in one of the spaces.

Boniface — 08 November at 08:42PM

Another sage tip:

Watch out for innocent-looking words that might actually be defs such as does and my

JPR — 08 November at 08:44PM

Don't forget to write.

PRS — 09 November at 12:20AM

Give up while you are still sane.

Of course, if you are reading this, it's too late; so take blank grid in one hand, indelible pen in the other, ensure you have an audience, then laugh uproariously, thus ensuring a lengthy stay in a nice quiet white room, with all the time in the world for your solution.

Criseyde — 09 November at 02:18AM

Find a place not too close to the computer to start with. Only go online when you're really stuck. Don't spend hours googling what you think is the definition. You're probably wrong and have forgotten the wordplay. Over time, bookmark useful tools like lists of cryptic abbreviations, indicators, thesauruses, dictionaries, anagram solvers from Aus, UK, US.

Read Puzzled, drop into a blog. Don't forget your family and friends .. you might need their General Knowledge (GK).

It's healthy (remember to breathe, eat,sleep etc.) It's fun, and it gets better with age.

RobT — 09 November at 08:49AM

Have a parent that loves cryptics.

Criseyde — 09 November at 09:52AM

For cryptic late-bloomers - you have life experience and the patience to enjoy the revelation of the code. Teach someone else as you go, or share the delight of a particular clue, often a good way to learn, even as a beginner .. at any age.

Love PRS' image. Make sure that a subscription is written into your 'enduring power of attorney'!

KM — 09 November at 03:14PM

Leave thine stack of crosswords (be they finished, unfinished or unstarted) where it will not cause annoyance to one's partner.

One Wheel — 09 November at 04:10PM

Ignore thy holy cover sense
---
Take every word for its full meaning

Em — 09 November at 10:00PM

If you're completely lost with what you think is an anagram, write the letters on pieces of paper and give them to your toddler to play with. Check back occasionally to see what she/he has spelt out. Or eaten.

When you start frequently rolling your eyes about, or quickly solving, clues in crosswords by a particular setter or publication, you're ready for the next level.

When you start frequently rolling your eyes about, or quickly solving, clues in crosswords by DA, you're ready for Mensa.

Do not leave half-finished crosswords near smarty-pants friends who will be unable to resist the urge to finish them. Quickly. In pen. Without scribblings.

JPR — 09 November at 10:18PM

Always let your conscience be your good Scots drug.
Praise God and pass the dictionary.

dg — 09 November at 11:10PM

Wow! Some weeks I'm ready for MENSA. Now all I need is a toddler. (Will a dog do? :)

JD — 13 November at 10:13AM

This is way past the deadline, but so true - If things move slowly on Saturday, be assured, Sunday morning will bring inspiration.

Leave a Comment

Only the comment field is required. Omitting the ID fields increases your risk of being mistaken for spam.

Preview or

Recent Comments

AC on (Wo)Men Acing Menacing at 19/05 at 04:38PM

RK on (Wo)Men Acing Menacing at 19/05 at 04:30PM

RobT on Salon 28 at 19/05 at 12:16PM

Mr X on Venez the Menace at 18/05 at 04:29PM

RV on Notes on a Sandal at 18/05 at 02:24PM

Jack on Notes on a Sandal at 18/05 at 01:11PM

MAUVE on Venez the Menace at 18/05 at 12:07PM

Tags

May 2012

April 2012

March 2012

February 2012

January 2012

December 2011

November 2011

October 2011

September 2011

August 2011

July 2011

June 2011

May 2011

April 2011

March 2011

February 2011

January 2011

December 2010

November 2010

October 2010

September 2010

August 2010