January 07 2011
Pass The Duckbill, Say
UTTER
MONOTREME
LAST SUPPER
What do those three have in common? Not sure, but this was the anointed trio for the clue-crafting competition, the four winners scoring a swag of books from Allen & Unwin, the publishers of Puzzled, plus a yearlong subscription to a paper of your choosing.

If you’re still holding your breath, a possible winner in the barrel, then exhale. Please. Since the four winners have been selected. Congratz to Susan Downing, Simon Birch, Robert Vere and David Carroll, at least one of whom is a regular Dabbler here, I discovered. Word for word, I’ve listed the winning clues below, plus a few other tangents from other contestants that caught my eye.
While the prizes have gone, and the horse has bolted, what kind of clue can you compose for the three words in question? (And for your sake, let’s hope they’re not super-brilliant, as you may have won something more than website kudos!)
UTTER
Nothing but talk (SD)
Cream, churned and skimmed, say (SB)
Unqualified flautist lost hand (RV)
Complete reversal of Caesar’s words at Last Supper (DC)
MONOTREME
Kimono tremendously enrobes a little native (SD)
Twin peaks on remote rock are a little Australian (SB)
Met no more unusual animal (RV)
Creator of eggs and milk cut, utter puzzler away from cathedral (DC)
LAST SUPPER
Purest pals’ spread?! (SD)
Loaves supplier declined olive and accepted senseless treason here! (SB)
Occasion to remember per St Paul’s version (RV)
Girl ate monotreme heart as stimulant, then nothing ever again? (DC)
Also like UTTER by Martin Gregory: No parking in golf club, say
(And Stuart Ray on a parallel tack: Quietly expelled from club, say)
Plus Konstanze Kwiet for her LAST SUPPER: Repast plus Betrayal!
Or June Redmond’s punny approach: The final sitting might leave you cross
So, the gauntlent is chucked. Can you eclipse the laureates?
Comments
Boniface — 07 January at 10:00AM
Spout?!
SK — 07 January at 10:29AM
UTTER- Entire b-b-boulevard demolished?
dg — 07 January at 11:12AM
So many ideas exhausted :(
UTTER: Air-blasted
Boniface — 07 January at 11:25AM
MONOTREME:
Classic Australian in Bremerton Omrah list (9).
DA — 07 January at 11:32AM
But that's the challenge, dg. Plenty of fine clues have been crafted before now, attached to plenty of long-chosen answers. The top setters find fresh turf.
One idea for MONOTREME I've been mulling:
Moonstruck (HBO series) seen streaming in Australia?
Boniface — 07 January at 11:53AM
LAST SUPPER:
Old painting moulds shoe leather?
SK — 07 January at 11:55AM
MONOTREME- Flash? Not me! (...removing a layer)
SK — 07 January at 12:26PM
LAST SUPPER- Historic dinner was a real piss up. I switched places with model and got hammered.
Boniface — 07 January at 01:37PM
MONOTREME:
Outrageous Aussie animal knocked over metronome
SK — 07 January at 03:38PM
Sorry, not sure if it's kosher to offer 2 clues per word, but I couldn't resist the following idea (inspired by Boniface's idea)-
MONOTREME- Aussie footballer was honoured to play fullback
Boniface — 07 January at 03:45PM
Tried posting this also for MONOTREME before but copped a bouncer:
Outrageous Aussie animal knocks over metronome.
Bit surprised that this ana wasn't picked up earlier though...
DA — 07 January at 04:02PM
Sorry 'bout that Boniface. Sometimes the odd words tied up in DA Posts can make the spam sieve shudder. I've unlocked your original send-in.
METRONOME was in fact used by several entrants, which made the maverick ideas more eye-catching.
SK, are you avoiding the definition element? I'm finding your stuff extra esoteric. Or am I off-beam today?
SK — 07 January at 04:18PM
I did put definitions in, DA....though apologise if a bit obscure. In order of appearance-
Utter = Entire
Monotreme = a layer
Last Supper = Historic dinner
Monotreme = Aussie (definition serving dual purpose with Emerton as an Aussie footballer)
SK — 07 January at 04:25PM
And wordplay-
Utter = b-b-boulevard demolished (stutter minus st)
Monotreme = flash (mo) + not + me re-moving (reme)
Last Supper = real piss up, switch i for t, hammered
Monotreme = Emerton OM
Boniface — 07 January at 04:26PM
My last one for MONOTREME:
Iconic Australian stooge took in comic mentor.
DA — 07 January at 05:59PM
Apologies SK - so you did, and artfully. That's sublime seeing a Socceroo in a playtpus.
And layer is crafty as well. I'd be pet food in a solving comp this afternoon.
Boniface, your stooge/mentor nestling is bewdiful. Only wished there were two more vouchers to give away.
SK — 07 January at 06:42PM
Ditto on Boniface's Moe...fabulous clue.
SK — 07 January at 07:01PM
And thanks DA...I kept thinking about how Emerton OM was a neat "full-back" of the subject word...tried to get Socceroo + platypus or echidna in a concept clue but couldn't come up with anything decent.
Nib — 07 January at 07:51PM
I like how DC cleverly entwined each definition twice.
UTTER:
State total.
MONOTREME:
Oviparous critter coins moonquake fluxmeter?
LAST SUPPER:
Art's supple prodded climactic spread.
Sam — 08 January at 09:16AM
UTTER:
Sheer hideout terrifying
Sam — 08 January at 11:06AM
MONOTREME:
Approach disturbing omen holding very French kind of mammal
Sam — 08 January at 11:25AM
LAST SUPPER (imagine Eucharist in italics):
Ballasts up per hull contents of the Eucharist
DA — 08 January at 11:36AM
That's a neat UTTER, Sam. Hide, the hidden-clue signpost is very well hidden.
JPR — 08 January at 04:35PM
Final feed lads? Top dude taken, disciples last seen in food-related party! Plan? Maker? (4,6)
ps *** spoiler alert Age today *** on treacherous nobleperson, yes he was hanged by the brits for treason tho he had irish and usa nationality, his brit passport was fake!!! where's the treason!?
Mauve — 09 January at 08:35AM
ah, I remember playing with these about 6 months ago...
UTTER:
Total maniac gets decapitated
LAST SUPPER:
Frazzled puzzlemaester drops ecstasy, then second drug, for ultimate summit
MONOTREME:
Platypus is swimming. Mermen too.
JPR — 09 January at 11:19AM
MONOTREME
Cultural element that can be transmitted -- imagine! Writer’s gal (model, right?) inside furry egg layer!
nice Zoolander reference Mauve
GymBunnies — 10 January at 07:55PM
DC is too brilliant for us. Could someone please spell out how his monotreme and last supper clues work?
DA, out of interest, how many entries did you have to judge? We thought there might have been a lot of verbose clues since the competition requested each clue "in 25 words or less" :-)
Boniface — 10 January at 08:42PM
DC's clues:
Girl (LASS) ate monotreme heart (T) as stimulant (UPPER), then nothing ever again (LAST SUPPER)?
Creator of eggs and milk (MONOTREME) cut, utter (MOW = MO) puzzler (DA) away from cathedral (NOTRE DAME).
Personally, I think clues over about 8 words cruel the surface reading, but there are exceptions...
dg — 10 January at 11:17PM
DC's were very impressive, hence my whinge earlier on. (I looked at 'monotreme' and saw 'mo' and 'notre dame' less 'DA' only to be amazed that someone else had already seen it.)
Though, of course, there can be luck in originality (and challenge)
GymBunnies — 11 January at 08:40AM
much appreciated, Boniface.
GymBunnies — 12 January at 11:20AM
Looking back at the original prizewinners I notice "senseless treason" to clue T, which was no doubt inspired by http://davidastle.com/blog/post/the-new-cryptic-alphabet/
Good to see previous brainstorms being leveraged.
But there's also "twin peaks", a visual clue for M, which seems obvious but I've never seen it before. Is this old hat?
Mauve — 12 January at 04:37PM
yes, I liked both SB's first clues but I don't see the anagram pointer for his Last Supper one (and the surface meaning is muddy). Taking olive out of "loaves supplier" only works if the letters are also then scrambled. Maybe "Corrupt loaves supplier" would have been better.
His monotreme was brilliant though (although "Twin peaks on remote rock layer" -to borrow someone else's "layer" idea might have been tidier)
GymBunnies — 12 January at 07:36PM
Hi Mauve,
Now you point it out, I agree "Twin peaks on remote rock layer" would have been pure gold, if a little difficult!
If you take the right olive out of "loaves supplier" (i.e. the o, 2nd l, i, v, and 1st e), and add the t in the right spot, then no anagram is required? I'm forgiving him the muddy surface given the smart wordplay and the fact it seems to be an &lit.
GymBunnies — 12 January at 07:45PM
p.s. My favourite winning clues were SD's "Nothing but talk" and "Purest pals' spread?!" for their purity and brevity. Quite memorable imho (if not as brilliant as DC's).
Mauve — 13 January at 12:00AM
Hi Gymbunnies
You're right, and my apologies to SB. As you detected, I was removing the wrong olive (story of my life ;-)