Diabolically Arcane

Puzzles, posts, news and general word-chat.

May 31 2011

Which/Witch Doctors Are Fake?

imagesCAQTG63G Imagine you’re stranded on a desert island. Which companion would you pick: John Howard or Daryl Somers? Imagine you had to change your career, which path would you take: toilet cleaner or abattoir worker? And while the dilemmas are running hot, which sin is more deadly: wrath or sloth?

Welcome to the hottest potato in the toyshop, a card-game called Which that forum regular, Mauve, has created. An evening’s entertainment of some 1260 dilemmas, across the spectrum of pop culture, prejudice, morality and humour. There’s no wrong answer, only laughter and debate. The game is also the prize for this week’s Storm, which deals with witch. Or homophones in fact.

The idea was sparked by another blog visitor, Tony Bracken. He had this to ask: Is there a name for a sentence or statement that makes perfect sense when spoken, but that cannot sensibly be written down? Such statements involve homophones, for example: “There are three twos in the English language.” Any thoughts?

Would love to hear how you label such a sentence, as well as other examples. Or is Tony’s sample part of an exclusive club? File your ID ideas, along with the week’s major Storm stuff: a homophone dilemma.

Invent a succinct sentence, and the right context, that makes one word interchangeable with its homophone, without the sentence losing any logic. Here’s one: My father always said that shipping was a great career, so I boarded a ship to sea/see.

And another: It’s important to keep a marshal/martial mindset during any conflict. So with Tony B’s word-gap to fill, with homophone dilemmas to create, and with Mauve’s provocative prize up for grabs, this Storm will define the week/weak.

Comments

IC — 31 May at 11:20AM

The insensible sentence is a great staple amongst some humourists. Stephen Fry, for example, used to have great fun writing sketches for "A Bit of Fry and Laurie" that generally involved a seemingly dry monologue undercut by humour arising from unexpected homonyms. One of my favourites...

"Anyway, I was on my way into work with Sir Peter Thorneycroft, no relation, one fresh June morning in early May and we took the short cut across the fields. I stooped to pick a buttercup, why people leave buttocks lying around, I've no idea. The gentlest breeze and mildest Camemberts were packed in our hamper and all nature seemed to be holding its breath."

Perhaps we should call them Fryisms in his honour?

Anthony Douglas — 31 May at 11:28AM

The architect's plans for our dream home were everything we'd ever wanted, but unfortunately, the fourth storey was going to push us beyond budget, forcing us to shed a tier/tear. We'll always have the storey/story to tell our grandkids about though.

There's plenty of scope for humour here (should we have saved it until Fryday?), but at the moment I'm afraid I just have no-eye deer.

RK — 31 May at 11:31AM

Ponting was bold/bowled coming down the pitch to the spinner.

IC — 31 May at 11:32AM

For the Greeks, the siege of Troy resulted in a hard fought/fort victory.

IC — 31 May at 11:37AM

Moses: writer/righter of wrongs.

RM formerly known as Rupert — 31 May at 11:38AM

Walking on the a'a near the top of the volcano will require tuff/tough footwear.

RM formerly known as Rupert — 31 May at 11:45AM

My grandfather had any number of these in the form of jokes, e.g.

Why is running a funeral home like planning a party?
Because you need to make sure you have the right number of biers/beers.

Working them into an actual sentence is harder.

DA — 31 May at 11:54AM

Shakespeare habitually recited filthy limericks at his local, which is why the man was barred/bard.

RM formerly known as Rupert — 31 May at 11:54AM

The management of the bankrupt dairy have lost their way/whey.

RM formerly known as Rupert — 31 May at 11:58AM

Identifying the front of a hooded cobra is easy, but few live to tell the tale/tail.

Mauve — 31 May at 12:00PM

"Gladly" the cross-eyed bear was a very loyal Christian. That was always my mum's favourite.

Although that strains boundaries with mondegreens or as the Coodabeens called them "mountaintops" (as in the Blue Mink song "What we need is a great big mountaintop")

The churchgoing bride's pledge "Aisle altar hymn" is another evergreen.

RM formerly known as Rupert — 31 May at 12:04PM

No-one knows what became of the person who stole the parson's fish, but there was much speculation on the eventual fate of his sole/soul.

Mauve — 31 May at 12:09PM

No talking allowed/aloud

Impatient for delivery of the handmade paste, the handmaid paced.

Mauve — 31 May at 12:13PM

and of course "Ablett resigns" has the opposite meaning to "Ablett resigns"

and "the barn was raised" is the opposite of "the barn was razed"

Boniface — 31 May at 12:38PM

If we don't go surfing then it ain't Gunnamatta/gunna matter.

My family has a farm out west, where the sons raise meat/sun's rays meet.

RK — 31 May at 12:42PM

Rejoice - a tax add-on saving the planet

Re Joyce: attacks ad on saving the planet

RM formerly known as Rupert — 31 May at 01:19PM

A bald king with no sons has no heir/hair apparent.

RM formerly known as Rupert — 31 May at 01:23PM

I bumped several people when I fell down the concrete steps, and I really felt the hard stairs/stares.

RM formerly known as Rupert — 31 May at 01:23PM

After dining on cheese, the cat sat outside the mouse hole with bated/baited breath.

IC — 31 May at 02:31PM

The house was purchased with a higher/hire purpose in mind.

JD — 31 May at 02:57PM

The dark K/nights were a constant feature through Victoria's record long reign/rain.

DA — 31 May at 03:37PM

The widow wore a crocheted/crow-shade shawl.

SK — 31 May at 03:40PM

This storm makes me think we should be channeling Benny Hill...

Masterchef judge pondered whether he should have added source/sauce to officiate/a fish he ate.

RM formerly known as Rupert — 31 May at 03:43PM

If we're going Benny Hill, I'm going to post this one:

Boy Scouts are teaching meditation to help scout leaders when they find themselves feeling intense/in tents.

RM formerly known as Rupert — 31 May at 03:45PM

Delivery carts in Kent are often four wheeled/for Weald.

Simon L — 31 May at 06:39PM

To complete the recipe the chef was wanting for/four more units of thyme/time.

CF — 31 May at 08:05PM

The sound of crashing waves resulted in a literal/littoral drowning out of our conversation.

RK — 31 May at 08:15PM

This is my foolhardy attempt to get as many homophones as I can into the one sentence. I tried to include root/route and one/won, but it didn't work out. It's a work in progress.

The guerilla warfare threw the peace into shreds.

The gorilla wore fair through the piece in two shreds.

CF — 31 May at 08:18PM

That summer I spent more time navel/naval gazing than an introspective Rear Admiral.

CF — 31 May at 08:23PM

The anxious editor cut-n-paced/paste furiously as the deadline approached.

CF — 31 May at 08:24PM

The infection spread to his lung, or lungs, pleural/plural

DA — 31 May at 08:26PM

Welcome aboard, CF. Wish you well in this week's Storm with a dual/duel dimension.

CF — 31 May at 08:29PM

The alley beside the newsagency was blocked by a stationary/stationery truck.

CF — 31 May at 09:06PM

Despite his proximal positioning, the Bishop could not readily gain access to the Queen, and was forced instead to sate his appetite by amassing a formidable porn/pawn collection.

CF — 31 May at 09:31PM

It was our coach's demanding training schedule made our rowing team a success, but the persistence of his homely assistant made our coxswain.

xobhcnul — 31 May at 11:51PM

Although variety is the spice of life, a steady rhythm is the sauce/source.

PRS — 01 June at 12:35AM

The Seekers had a song about a lonely Kiwi - "I'll never find another you/ewe"

and, from Waltzing Matilda

And he/Andy sat and watched.....

PRS — 01 June at 01:02AM

The mountains peak/peek above the clouds.

PRS — 01 June at 01:13AM

The excess high-calorie food went to waist/waste.

PRS — 01 June at 01:26AM

With the wrong ingredients, I can't beat/beet the salad.

To obtain a perfect flame, you need a perfect match. (flame = mate/fire, match = fit/fire lighter

PRS — 01 June at 01:28AM

Excess warfarin/war-faring leads to blood loss.

CF — 01 June at 06:57AM

If Batman can be called at home on the Batphone, can Robin be summoned on the Homophone?

CF — 01 June at 07:10AM

The base camp of Everest is as far as many people get. Some were determined to ascend despite inclement weather but there was a lot of dissent/descent.

CF — 01 June at 07:19AM

"Blood really is thicker than water" thought detective Gannon, as he retrieved the settled sample from the lab, phialled under pee.

CF — 01 June at 07:30AM

To share twenty-two pies amongst seven people can be a challenge; you risk cutting inequatible portions unless you're really familiar with pi/pie.

RM (the dabbler formerly known as Rupert) — 01 June at 08:19AM

Professional carpet layers rarely make much money because they have to pay out so much for tacks/tax.

RM (the dabbler formerly known as Rupert) — 01 June at 08:29AM

The carnival owner chose to walk to the bank rather than take the bus, even though he could afford to pay his fare/fair.

RM (the dabbler formerly known as Rupert) — 01 June at 08:35AM

The wind blew fiercely across the village cricket pitch, as the farmers at the crease kept a wary eye on their haystacks in the distance, afraid the gale would remove their bales/bails.

PRS — 01 June at 09:00AM

After his cataract operation, Jonhhy Nash sang "I/eye can see clearly now."

PRS — 01 June at 09:03AM

Cannibals greeting missionaries: "We're pleased to meet/meat you"

RM (the dabbler formerly known as Rupert) — 01 June at 09:48AM

Much of the hot air in Munich comes from the phone/Fohn.

RM (the dabbler formerly known as Rupert) — 01 June at 09:56AM

Boat for sale/sail.

Slightly more convolutedly:

My part of the co-owned yacht is for sale/foresail.

RK — 01 June at 10:13AM

I know the brief is to only have one homophone pair in the sentence, but I seem to be drawn to multiples, even if only for my own amusement.

Chased girl one night.

Chaste girl won knight.

Nib — 01 June at 10:48AM

I think this qualifies as a quadruple:
The bankrupt perfume salesman with a case of anosmia had a clear lack of sense/cents/scents.

The triathlete's path was rowed, rode and road.

Born inbred in Tasmania.

The overweight drug dealer, who delivered his wares by bicycle, was arrested for pedalling crack.

Though the better one/ bettor won, got double and partied.

*CRUDITY WARNING*
The perverted musician fingered a G string, tinkled with a pianist and blew A Flat Minor.

The farmer receding/reseeding through his tall crop soon got lost in the maze/maize.

The haggis here is just offal.

The Athiest Society is a non-prophet organisation.

JD — 01 June at 11:36AM

The Magi honoured baby Jesus with their presents/presence.

RK — 01 June at 11:40AM

The wealthy gave alms/arms to the struggling underclass.

After several days of irregularity, Peter took time in lieu/in loo.

JD — 01 June at 11:42AM

Calls to mind an old saying:
She offered her honour, he honoured her offer, so all night long it was honour, offer, honour offer.

DA — 01 June at 11:49AM

This Storm really is bringing out the old nyuk-nyuks. None of which will win Which, but still plenty of fun to relive.

Working on the rooftop, the sweep sneezed and came down with the flu/e.

RK — 01 June at 12:31PM

He played the liar/lyre with deceptive mastery.

RK — 01 June at 12:45PM

She plucked the loot/lute from the stage.

Mauve — 01 June at 01:52PM

This may not get through the filter so I'll censor it...

As Werribee Sewerage Farm pumped its waste out into the bay, families swam there undeterred/under____

IC — 01 June at 03:12PM

Though toothless and swigging moonshine, he wasn't comfortable with the appellation/Appalachian hillbilly.

SK — 01 June at 04:25PM

On the road in Asia-

Newspaper stories added to the pressure forcing a poor/for Singapore government minister to resign.

Or perhaps something more contemporary (and certainly more believable)-

The facts emerged about "FIFA/fee for votes" scandal.

RV — 01 June at 06:05PM

For most young Aussies reckon sillier tree climbing behaviour is to decline.

RV — 01 June at 06:48PM

Don't just whine - cry wolf. Blasphemy!

SK — 01 June at 07:55PM

Frequent application of hot wax ultimately results in pure brazilians/pube resilience.

PJ — 01 June at 08:34PM

The pastor, standing over the lifeless body of Bambi's mother, solemnly began the service: "Deerly beloved..."

HE — 01 June at 08:45PM

From glee:

New directions/nude erections

Boniface — 01 June at 09:00PM

Unstable oak shot through with white-ants.
Unstable Oakeshott through with white-ants.

Boniface — 01 June at 09:33PM

WHO says cell phones cause cancer.
Who says, 'Sell phones, cause cancer'?

RV — 01 June at 09:45PM

After the long trip home to Europe, conquistador to write "On the nose!" (Con kissed a daughter right on the nose).

RM formerly known as Rupert — 02 June at 05:56AM

Can't believe we haven't had this one yet:

My family have kept sheep for generations, so I heard/herd.

JD — 02 June at 09:34AM

The sick SP bookie in the aviary took a tern for the bettor.

JD — 02 June at 10:26AM

Smut alert!! Hopefully doesn't venture too far beyond the line of respectability. I didn't make it up by the way.

The gay oyster that slipped off a rock and pulled a muscle.

RK — 02 June at 11:37AM

The opposing fans arrived at the ground, accompanied by boos/booze.

The exquisite choral/coral piece faded away in the night.

Anthony Douglas — 02 June at 01:45PM

This one's going into print (this week's church bulletin) - it's my only way to beat Boniface's current affairs up-to-the-minute approach...

Sylvia has an old chest freezer to give away, so talk to her if you'd like to get a little cooler.

DA2 — 03 June at 04:06PM

xxxxx

Thanks for this suite/sweet of aural ideas. The Storm has now abated, with deadline expiring y'day. Will announce our Which winner, plus a shortlist of the snazziest entries, early next week, when I'm back in the Word Cave.

Mr X — 03 June at 09:12PM

Damn, I missed the deadline. The following sounds like it should be the punchline of an old joke but I think it's original:

The stubborn little piece of leather said "I won't be suede/swayed."

philth — 04 June at 05:54AM

so as usual I'm too late to play, but just wanted to add something which is a bit of a generalisation of this...

due to recent travels in paris, i was exposed to someone who showed me a holorhyme (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holorime):

Par le bois du djinn, où s'entasse de l'effroi
Parle, bois du gin, ou cent tasses de lait froid

i tried and tried to get something equivalent in english, and all i could come up with were fairly short examples like

know your pain...
no, you're payin'

which isn't really getting into the spirit of splitting syllables over different words.

maybe some of the stormers could brew up some better examples for the english language - i did a google search and wasn't able to find any sort of list or even more than a couple of examples that seem to be the only ones going around.

any takers?

Mauve — 04 June at 09:45AM

philth, my ""Gladly", the cross-eyed bear" and "Gladly, the cross I'd bear" post above fits more into your idea than into the idea of this thread

dosialite — 13 January at 11:13PM

photos Company teases [URL=http://dietapractice.ru/dlya-poxudeniya-zhivota-sredstva/]Правда о таблетках для похудения[/URL]
computer enthusiasts with two tablets [URL=http://fitnessdieta.ru/silnye-tabletki-dlya-poxudeniya/]Видео физкультура для похудения[/URL]
that are unlike anything we have seen from Sony before.
Social information is spreading [URL=http://dietapractice.ru/leda-tabletki-dlya-poxudeniya/]Леда таблетки для похудения[/URL]
across the Web, and [URL=http://fitnessdieta.ru/lekarstva-dlya-bystrogo-poxudeniya/]Видео физкультура для похудения[/URL]
Google search can't ignore its value. [URL=http://fitnessdieta.ru/sistema-poxudeniya-e-malyshevoj/]Видео физкультура для похудения[/URL]
But are Facebook and Twitter selling, and will Google pay?

RobT — 27 January at 06:37AM

Witch doctors, indeed.

Leave a Comment

Only the comment field is required. Omitting the ID fields increases your risk of being mistaken for spam.

Preview or

Recent Comments

Sam on Modern Families at 22/05 at 11:38AM

DA on Salon 29 - Marinara Version at 22/05 at 11:25AM

AC on Salon 29 - Marinara Version at 22/05 at 11:14AM

JT on Salon 29 - Marinara Version at 22/05 at 10:38AM

SK on WoW: Zonkerpede at 22/05 at 07:37AM

anax on Salon 29 - Marinara Version at 21/05 at 10:06PM

Boniface on Salon 29 - Marinara Version at 21/05 at 08:05PM

Tags

May 2012

April 2012

March 2012

February 2012

January 2012

December 2011

November 2011

October 2011

September 2011

August 2011

July 2011

June 2011

May 2011

April 2011

March 2011

February 2011

January 2011

December 2010

November 2010

October 2010

September 2010

August 2010